Ankle fractures are breaks of the distal tibia or fibula (near or in the the so- called malleolus); occasionally, they involved the shaft of the fibula as well. Ankle fractures range from a simple injuries of a single bone to complex ones involving multiple bones and ligaments. Twisting with the foot planted on the ground and the body rotating around it is the most common mechanism of injury. (Compression is more apt to produce a fractures of the weight-bearing surface of the distal tibia, the plafond; these are designated as “pilon fractures", and are considered distinctly.) Ankle fractures can be broadly divided into stable or unstable injuries. Stable fractures typically heal with immobilization and protected weight bearing whereas operative management is needed for displaced or unstable fractures. Some residual arthrosis is not uncommon even if the bone heals perfectly.
Structure and function
The ankle joint is made up of the tibia, fibula, and talus. The tibia forms the superior and medial aspects of the joint, and the fibula its lateral aspect. The talus is a cube-shaped lower bone that sits above the calcaneus and below the tibial plafond. The distal ends of the fibula and tibia that overlap the talus are known as the malleoli (“little hammers”): the lateral malleolus is the distal end of the fibula, whereas the medial and posterior malleoli are part of the tibia. A fracture affecting both the medial and lateral malleoli is called a bimalleolar fracture, and one involving the medial, lateral, and posterior malleoli is called a trimalleolar fracture.
The ankle joint also contains three important ligament complexes: the deltoid ligament medially, connecting the tibia to the talus and calcaneus; the talo-fibular and calcaneo-fibular ligaments (collectively the lateral collateral ligaments); and the syndesmosis which connects the distal tibia and fibula above the tibio-talar joint line.
Figure: Anatomy of the ankle joint. Medially, the deltoid ligament (shown in pink) connects the tibia to the talus and calcaneus; laterally the calcaneofibular (green) and talofibular (yellow) ligaments stabilize the joint. The syndesmosis (red) between the tibia and fibula holds these bones together at the appropriate distance.
The tibial plafond, lateral malleolus, and medial malleolus form a mortise, a socket in which the talus sits. Although the ligaments are needed to give the ankle its full stability, the bony congruity of the mortise and the talus is a necessary component.
Figure: The ankle forms a mortise and tenon (carpentry version shown at right). The mortise (the socket) comprises the lateral malleolus, the tibial plafond, and the medial malleolus. The tenon (or tongue) is the talus. As seen, the talus is wedged into a space just big enough to hold it.
When the mortise is disrupted by a fracture, the talus is free to move more than it should. This abnormal motion leads to focal loading on small segments of the bone, with the overall contact area between the tibia and talus reduced.
Because stress is equal to the force (load) divided by area, a smaller area of contact can markedly increase the stress on the bones. Accordingly, a seemingly minor joint subluxation (eg 2mm of lateral talar shift) can promote reactive bone formation (following Wolff's Law, which states that bone grows in response to load). This new bone is more rigid than normal bone (ie, scleroitic, with decreased compliance) and ultimately can wear out more quickly, yielding post-traumatic arthrosis. (Note that arthrosis may resulty from direct to the hyaline cartilage at the time of injury too.)
There are many methods of classifying ankle fractures: some are too simple (and therefore not very informative), and others provide more detailed information yet become unwieldy and unreliable (and therefore not very informative either). It may be best, therefore to describe ankle fractures by the bones involved (i.e., isolated medial/lateral malleolar, bimalleolar, trimalleolar, etc.) and the presence of absence of soft tissue injury. (Regarding the soft tissues, the single most important feature to note is whether the fracture is "open", that is, that the skin is broken).
Another important consideration is the stability of the ankle joint. Ankle fractures are classified as stable if the fracture is non-displaced or minimally displaced and the medial structures (deltoid ligament and medial malleolus) are intact. This type of injury allows the talus to remain within the mortise, preventing displacement of the joint.
Figure: Plain x-ray of a stable ankle fracture. Note the mortise is intact: the space surrounding the talus is normal. Credit: http://www.footeducation.com/stable-ankle-fracture
Ankle fractures are unstable if the injury allows the talus to be move within the mortise.
Figure: Plain x-ray of an unstable ankle fracture (white (fibula) and pink (tibia)arrows). Note how the talus (outlined in purple) is displaced laterally along with the fibular fragment and no longer sits snugly within the distorted mortise (red). Modified from http://www.footeducation.com/ankle-fracture
The fracture pattern often provides useful clues not only regarding the mechanism of injury but whether there are associated lesions (that may not be apparent on the xray). For example, a transverse fracture (as shown in the figure) is clearly produced by traction. Yet for this traction force to be produced, the foot must move medially, perhaps creating an impact on the medial side. Similarly, an oblique fibular fracture is produced by twisting, which in turn can cause a tension injury on the medial side.
Figure: A transverse fracture of the fibula is produced by a traction force, depicted by the arrow. The motion of the foot needed to produce this force may cause the talus to hit the tibia medially, producing a bone bruise if the force is mild (as shown by the star) or even a fracture on this side as well (not shown).
Figure: An oblique fracture of the fibula (red arrow) is produced by twisting. This force also applies traction to the medial side. Here a small fleck of bone is pulled off the tibia (yellow arrow) along with the deltoid ligament. Although the ligament cannot be "seen" on the xray, the injury is easily inferred, given the widening of the mortise nearby.
(modified from http://images.radiopaedia.org/images/155032/faec4668ee511c885b53520a2dd23a_big_gallery.jpg and http://images.radiopaedia.org/images/3781/f8be1ee7dc901f86e4bec70d6bf8e0.jpg)
Patients with ankle fractures usually present with immediate and severe pain, swelling, and bruising following an acute injury. Patients typically describe an acute twisting injury in which the foot is planted on the ground and the body rotates around it.
The direction of rotation and the orientation of the foot while planted will determine which bones and ligaments may be injured. While this is useful information to obtain, it is often the case that the patient cannot recall or describe exactly what happened. Nonetheless, it is important to obtain a history of the general mechanism of injury, to help guide further investigation. For example, ankle pain after a fall from a great height or a motor vehicle crash is likely to be from force transmitted from the heel up the leg, and therefore injury to the calcaneus, talus and more proximal bones (including even the spine) must be considered.
Patients with suspected ankle fractures should have xrays performed: an anterior-posterior (AP) view and a lateral. Shooting the AP with the foot slightly internally rotated aout 15 degrees produces a clearer view of the mortise. These views should be evaluated for the integrity of the bones as well as proper alignment between joint surfaces.
Figure: Internal rotation of the foot will give a clearer view of the mortise. Without such rotation, the fibula, which is slightly posterior, will overlap with the tibia (red circle) making it difficult to assess the symmetry of the joint space (white arrows)
modified from http://www.radiologyassistant.nl/data/bin/a5097979b53e58_Mortise.jpg
Not all patients with ankle injuries should be "suspected" of having an ankle fracture. Indeed, according one study (PMID: 15496699) of acute ankle injuries in the Emergency Department, sprains outnumber fractures by an 8:1 ratio. To help guide the decision whether imaging is needed, the Ottawa Ankle Rules have been developed. According to these rules, ankle radiographs are not necessary if malleolar (bony) tenderness is absent and the patient can bear weight. To apply these rules, it is important, of course, to recognize surface anatomy of the malleoli.
In some patients an unstable ankle fracture is only diagnosed after the ankle is "stress" under x-ray revealing the lateral displacement of the talus and therefore disruption of the deltoid ligament.
According to Lin et al (PMID: 21655420), ankle fractures occur in the USA with an incidence of approximately 187 fractures per 100,000 people per year. Fracture incidence by age is bimodal, with men typically having higher rates as young adults and women having higher rates as elderly adults. The highest incidence is found in elderly white women.
The most common type of ankle fracture is an isolated fibular fracture, representing about half of all ankle fractures. One-fourth of ankle fractures are bimalleolar, while trimalleolar fractures and isolated medial malleolar fractures are less common. Only 2% of ankle fractures are open.
When a patient presents with an acute ankle injury, is necessary to discern which structures, if any, have been damaged.
Injuries that cause ankle fractures may also cause damage outside of the ankle region per se. For example, a twisting injury to the foot and ankle may send for through the syndesmosis and interosseous membrane, up the leg, leading to a fracture in the proximal fibula near the knee, a so-called Maisonneuve fracture. The figures demonstrate a fracture of the posterior malleous. This injury is produced by a strong external rotation force, one that would assuredly damage the lateral side as well. Yet no fibular injury is seen near the ankle. In this case, the lateral injury was to the proximal fibula --an injury that would not be detected unless xrays were obtained there. (This underscores the rule: "fracture films must show the joint above and the joint below".) This injury is important to detect given the proximity of the common peroneal nerve to the fracture line.
Figures: a Maisonneuve fracture. The top views reveal a posterior malleolar fracture (white arrow), with no apparent lateral side damage. The images below show the fibular fracture (green arrow).
It is also possible that injuries that seemingly affect the ankle will actually be foot injuries. Injuries to the tarsometatarsal (Lisfranc) joint and the navicular and posterior tibial tendon and fractures of the fifth metatarsal can easily be missed if attention is paid to only the ankle itself.
Blood on the skin is suggestive of an open fracture and any break in the skin associated with an ankle fracture should be considered an open fracture until proven otherwise. Open fractures require administration of antibiotics and tetanus prophylaxis as indicated. Basic wound management (cleaning the wound with saline and applying a dressing and splint) should not await the arrival of a specialist.
If a patient presents with severe ankle pain following an acute injury but x-rays are normal, they may have an injury to the foot and not the ankle, such as a Lisfranc joint disruption or navicular fracture. It is important to evaluate the midfoot to catch any injuries that might mimic the presentation of an ankle fracture.
Diabetic patients who fracture their ankles pose a unique challenge, especially if their diabetes is uncontrolled (HgA1C >7%). They have a much higher risk of developing a post-operative infection if surgery is indicated. Additionally, they are at high risk for developing a Charcot ankle arthropathy which is a destructive arthritis associated with neuropathy.
If the patient’s growth plates are open, a growth plate injury should be suspected (and protected) if there is bony tenderness, despite "normal" xrays.
The presence of a pilon fracture should suspicion of associated injuries, due to the higher energy nature of this fracture
Treatment options and outcomes
Initial management of all ankle fractures should consist of reduction in the case of a dislocated fracture and basic wound management (sterilization, dressing, and prophylactic antibiotics) in the case of an open fracture. The ankle should then be immobilized with a splint and elevated to minimize swelling.
After initial management, decisions regarding definitive treatment can be made. If the fracture is stable and not displaced, non-operative treatment may suffice. Non-operative treatment consists of immobilization and protected weight bearing for about 6 weeks. Frequent radiographs are necessary to monitor for displacement and to ensure that proper alignment is maintained over the course of treatment. Following adequate bone healing, physical therapy will be necessary to help the patient regain strength, range of motion, and proprioceptive function.
Operative fixation will be necessary if there is displacement of the bone fragments or disruption of the mortise. Surgery generally consists of making incisions at the affected malleoli, re-positioning the bony fragments to their appropriate positions, and holding them in place with screws and plates. The hardware can be left in the joint permanently unless it causes irritation, in which case it can be removed once the fracture has healed.
Figure: Fracture fixation with a plate and screws is shown. The longer screw (arrow) into the tibia is used to reduce the mortise, that is, to hold the tibia and fibula at the correct distance to allow the ligaments normally holding them to heal. modified from http://images.radiopaedia.org/images/356279/3dfe2c38e63c6a6e83cb2b5e69e6cd.jpg)
Outcomes for stable fractures treated non-operatively are generally excellent. Ankle fractures treated with operative fixation heal uneventfully in approximately 85% of the cases. Not surprisingly, outcomes improve with more accurate reduction. Factors that negatively affect outcomes include involvement of the posterior malleolus, impaction of the talus, severe talar dislocation, and diabetic status of the patient. Recovery time will depend on the severity of the initial injury but it often takes a year or more before patients reach their point of maximal improvement. Even then, mild to moderate symptoms may persist for years despite complete radiographic healing.
Complications of ankle fractures include malunion, non-union, stiffness, and wound complications. Even with optimal treatment, some ankle fractures may result in post-traumatic ankle arthrosis: damage to the articular surface at the time of injury can lead to chondrocyte death.
Sub-optimal reduction of the joint and resultant abnormal biomechanics will also promote the development of arthrosis.
Another possible, albeit rare, complication of ankle fractures is complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) which was previously known as reflex sympathetic dystrophy syndrome. This uncommon but debilitating condition is characterized by burning or throbbing pain, sensitivity to cold or touch, weakness, stiffness, and changes in skin color, temperature, or texture.
Risk factors and prevention
Valtola et al and Honkanen et al (PMID: 11792591, 9692074) found that primary risk factors for ankle fracture are cigarette smoking and a high body mass index. According to Seeley et al (PMID: 8864910), although low bone density is a risk factor for other fractures, it is not considered a major risk factor for ankle fractures.
An avulsion fracture of the ankle (a small fleck of bone seen on radiographs just distal to a malleolus) is really an ankle sprain. The primary injury is to the ligament, not the bone. The fleck seen is a fragment tugged off the bone when the ligament was pulled, much like a piece of masking tape yanked briskly from a wall may take with it a sliver of paint as well. (That piece of paint, one might say, has been “avulsed” from the wall.) An avulsion fracture is not a structurally significant bone injury but its presence informs the viewer that an ankle sprain is present.
Ottawa Ankle Rules
Physically examine an injured ankle and determine the extent of injury and structures involved
Apply the Ottawa Ankle Rules to decide which patients require radiographic evaluation
Describe radiographic findings and use radiographs to identify fractures, infer ligamentous injuries, and recognize instability and displacement
Differentiate between stable and unstable ankle fractures
Provide first-line treatment to open fractures (wound management) and dislocations (gross reduction and splinting)